Can We Afford It?
It seems like every time the subject of “Medicare for All” comes up, the discussion immediately goes to some variant of “how are you going to pay for it” with the implication being it’s so costly we can’t possibly afford it.
And the discussion usually stops right there because the obvious answer is that we need to increase tax revenue which scares people, and rightly so. What’s frustrating is that we almost never continue the discussion past that rhetorical roadblock.
So, here’s a thought experiment. What would it cost? And can we afford it?
What Does It Cost
First question to answer is how much does Medicare cost? That’s easy – we spend roughly $700 billion annually to pay for Medicare.
Second question is how is it paid for? A direct, mandatory income tax of 2.9% shared between employee & employer equally at 1.45% each with an additional tax of 2.35% on income over $200,000. Which is kind of silly because that “employer paid” 1.45% is factored into the cost of your compensation either way. Total household income in the US is approximately $16.4 trillion, 2.9% of which approximately $476 billion, leaving a shortfall of around $225 billion which is made up for by the tax on high incomes, premiums paid, interest, and "general revenue". Medicare financing is a little complicated, there's parts A, B, C, & D which cover different things and are paid for differently.
How much does it cost per capita? How much of that $700 billion is spent per person? It varies by state, but it averages out to about $10,000 per person which is inline with per capita healthcare spending across in the US.
Given that it’s covering people who need more care than average, that’s an interesting observation, but more on that later.
The Medicare tax goes back to 1965, too. It’s been around for quite a while.
How Much Would It Cost For Everyone
I think it makes sense to separate this question from what should it cost since healthcare costs in the US are an extreme outlier. No one pays more than we do and many get better results for less money.
Leaving that question aside, let’s just take what it currently costs to provide healthcare and figure out what would it take to pay for it.
Currently annual healthcare costs in the US are $3.5 trillion, but not all of that is paid for by Medicare or private insurance. And not all of it is actually "healthcare" per se.
|Private Health Insurance||$1,184,000,000,000|
|Out of Pocket (Cash $)||$365,000,000,000|
|Department of Defense||$42,000,000,000|
|Childrens Health Insurance||$18,000,000,000|
|Other (Including Research)||$265,000,000,000|
What if we just upped the Medicare tax to cover private insurance and out of pocket, an additional $1.5 trillion? It would need to go from 2.9% to about 12%, or an additional 9%.
|Annual Income||Tax Rate||Annual Contribution||Monthly||Split|
The table above show what the annual and monthly contributions are and would be based on the current and hypothetical rates would be. I’m using the average household income, currently about $61,000, as the basis for comparison. The “split” column shows the 50/50 split between employee & employer. But remember, that “employer paid” business is really kind of a fiction anyway since the employer is factoring that cost into what they pay you regardless.
That sounds shocking ... how could we expect everyone to pay an additional 10% in tax? An extra $225 per month for the average household?
What Do You Pay Now
The most obvious problem with this argument that we can’t afford it ignores the fact that we’re already paying it. The $3.5 tillion is a measure of what we currently spend.
What’s the average insurance premium for a household in the US? It’s $1,600 per month for a family group insurance plan. All of a sudden $225 sounds like one hell of a bargain. In fact even up to four times the average household income, 93% of all households, the hypothetical maximum is still probably lower than what those households likely already pay. High income families tend to have premium plans that cost much more than the average.
|Income Level||Current Medicare||Medicare for All|
The table above shows the employee portion of the current Medicare tax and the hypothetical maximum based on covering all healthcare costs currently paid privately. Remember too, if you’re paying for Medicare, you don’t also need to pay for private insurance. You’re costs for pretty much everyone up to four times the average income go down. By a lot.
Yes, I’m ignoring the fact that the approximately 7% of households that earn more than four times the average are going to see their costs go up. Cry me a river. What we have right now is a "regressive" policy where you pay proportionally more the less you make. Medicare isn't even "progressive" where you pay proportionally more the more you make (like income tax), it's a flat tax.
What Would It Really Cost
I have no idea how much it would really cost. What’s described above is the theoretical maximum. What it would take to pay every single dollar paid by a citizen now, either directly out of pocket or indirectly by a private insurance policy, out of Medicare.
Realistically, that’s not the right target, though.
First of all Medicare is cheaper to administer than private insurance. Medicare has a roughly 2-3% administrative overhead whereas the average private insurance administrative overhead is ten times that, 20-30%. So the private insurance costs wouldn't be identical.
Second, insurance isn’t paying the $3.5 trillion of current costs. It’s really closer to 35%, or around $1.2 trillion, so it's a false choice to say Medicare has to cover $3.5 trillion in costs.
Third, our costs are absurdly high. Our current per capita healthcare costs of $10,000 should be closer to $5,000 if we were in line with other, similar countries. So our total costs should be around $1.75 trillion with insurance paying about $600 billion of that and about $170 billion out of pocket.
Take that into account and the Medicare for All mega-tax is now down around 5%, not 12%. That means split with the employer the average household would be paying about $130 a month in Medicare tax. Any everyone would have healthcare with no out of pocket expense.
Can we afford it? How can we not?
But You Can’t Get There From Here
There are two big obstacles to achieving this, though. Well, three really.
- The top 10% or so of households would see their tax burden increase. They will fight it tooth & nail.
- The healthcare industry needs to go on a diet. They cost too much. A lot of people who make a ton of money will see their incomes cut. The will fight that tooth & nail.
- Taxes. Getting a tax increase passed in our current political climate seems unlikely.
How Could You Do It?
We’ve got to simultaneously lower costs and provide more money.
One option might be to establish a “minimum standard of care” and simply pay for that for everyone. Sort of a national HMO, if you will. Everyone gets basic care paid for by the government funded by a Medicare-like tax. If you want more and can afford it, you buy private supplemental insurance.
Keep the maximum per capita cost at some reasonable minimum, say $3,500, raise the Medicare tax to around 4%, raise the additional high income tax to 3%, and let the insurance companies cover the gap for those with means.
Remember that Medicare pays approximately $10,000 per capita for those it covers currently? Those are the segment of the population that statistically get the most care; the elderly & the disabled. Younger, healthier people would cost much less to cover.
|Income Level||Current Medicare||Basic Medicare for All|
The table above shows how little it would cost to provide some minimum care for everyone, leaving plenty of money on the table for those that can afford it to get "better" healthcare. It's still worse than what wealthy countries do for their citizens, but it's better than what we have.
If we don’t do something, the system will most likely collapse. We can’t keep paying nearly 18% of our GDP to get worse care than our peer nations and still leave millions of people with no access to any healthcare.